There’s an argument to be made that perfection is unattainable, or even something abstract. It definitely feels that way when it comes to entertainment, because, even when it comes to all-time favorites, there are usually nitpicks or tiny things wrong, at the very least. Perfection might be a good thing to aim for, because the closer one gets to it, the better… but achieving it quite literally is exceedingly difficult, if not impossible.
So, when looking at one genre – hey, let’s sayscience fiction– there are plenty of works contained within that are great, and even close to perfect, but not quite there. These films arguably fit that definition,usually impressing in multiple areas while having at least one definable flaw, or a small number of slight missteps, that hold them back from being perfect. Though, at the end of the day, near-perfect still equals some level of excellence; that shouldn’t be forgotten.
10’District 9' (2009)
Director: Neill Blomkamp
2009 was a good year for the sci-fi genre, withDistrict 9being one significant contributor to that. It combined body horror with satire/social commentary and some over-the-top action for good measure, being about an alien spacecraft that becomes stranded over the city of Johannesburg. This makes the aliens refugees, and their race is discriminated against by humanity, and exploited by some.
It uses a science fiction story to look at prejudice and reflect the apartheid era in South Africa, which lasted most of the second half of the 20th century.District 9falters in a few areas, with somequestionable characterizations when it came to certain human characters and a conclusion that some may feel lacks finality, but the film is undoubtedly creative, and manages to achieve a great deal with what was a relatively small budget, as far as sci-fi movies withgroundbreaking special effects go ($30 million).
District 9
Watch on AMC+
9’Looper' (2012)
Director: Rian Johnson
Looperendeavors todo a great deal within a runtime of less than two hours, telling an engaging story about time travel and assassins. Targets for assassinations get sent back in time, with the assassins waiting for them, all done because killing and disposing of people is exceedingly difficult in the future. The assassins are well-paid, but part of their job involves one day killing their future selves before retiring.
Complications ensue whenJoseph Gordon-Levitt’s future self, played byBruce Willis, is sent back in time, but the former proves unable to kill the latter. It’s a strange but excellently engaging premise… for a while. It stumbles a bit as it reaches its final act, which feels disappointingly small in scope and a little underwhelming compared tothe fast-paced and more action-packedfirst two acts of the film.
Watch on Netflix
8’Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse' (2023)
Directors: Joaquim Dos Santos, Justin K. Thompson, Kemp Powers
Thealmost five-year wait betweenSpider-Man: Into the Spider-VerseandSpider-Man: Across the Spider-Versewas largely worth it. The original wasa breath of fresh air among superhero movies, telling an origin story without feeling redundant or overly familiar. The animation style and sense of humor certainly helped, too, with Into the Spider-Verse hitting every note it needed to.
If that 2018 film was perfect, then 2023’sAcross the Spider-Versewas… well, not quite perfect, but close. The only real hiccup to enjoying or fully appreciating it was the fact it felt unfinished, with a downright cruel/jarring cliffhanger that didn’t seem so bad when the thirdSpider-Versemovie was scheduled for 2024. Butnow there have been delays, and as of 2024, the release date isn’t well-known. If that film comes out and perfectly wraps up all the threads left hanging in Across the Spider-Verse, then it might seem like a perfect two-parter in hindsight. But, until then, it does feel ever so slightly frustrating.
Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse
7’Woman in the Moon' (1929)
Director: Fritz Lang
Woman in the Moonis aFritz Langmovie thatlives eternally (and unfairly) in the shadowof the filmmaker’s 1927 masterpiece,Metropolis. Both are epic science fiction movies that still hold up remarkably well considering they’re each approaching a century old.Metropolisis almost certainly the best sci-fi film of the silent era, and Woman in the Moon isn’t too far beyond quality-wise.
That is, it’s similarly strong on a technical front, and exhibits a similar amount of creativity, especially when it comes to the special effects utilized to show a voyage to the moon nearly 40 years before the real thing.Where it stumbles a little, however, is in the melodrama and romance departments, with the conflict between certain space travelers feeling a little undercooked compared to the more adventurous aspects of the film.
Buy on Amazon
6’Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2' (2017)
Director: James Gunn
The firstGuardians of the Galaxy, released in 2014, is more or lessperfect, as far as superhero movies go. It expertly introduces a bunch of flawed but endearing characters, gives them a reason to form an unlikely team, and gradually shows them getting closer and becoming the titular Guardians of the Galaxy by the film’s end. Along the way, there’s plenty of action, humor, and heartfelt moments.
Then, in 2017,Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2was released,and it was a film of massive highs and occasional lows. There’s a good three-quarters of the movie that’s pretty much just as good asGuardians of the Galaxy(2014), and its emotional moments arguably hit harder… though it’s just not balanced quite as well, with humor sometimes undermining more serious moments and the tone feeling overall a little chaotic. This is never in a way that stopsGuardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2from being entertaining, but it ultimately doesn’t feel quite as thrilling or as effortless as the first.
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
Watch on Disney+
5’Nope' (2022)
Director: Jordan Peele
First and foremost, you do have to admire the wayJordan Peele’s films have gradually increased in scope while retaining a fairly comparable level of quality.Get Outis his smallest but arguably most intense/interesting, whileUsupped the scale of things and proved unsettling in similar ways. Then along cameNope, which felt considerably bigger,taking on science fiction elements in a big way and feeling quite epic in parts, especially throughout the spectacular third act.
Before that final act, though,Nopeis a slow burn that comes a little too close to being too slow, at times (and not many).Get Outwas a tight 104 minutes,Uswas 12 minutes longer, and thenNopewas 14 minutes longer than that. It’s a nitpick to say something 130 minutes long was too long, but maybe just a little tighteningcould’ve madeNopemore consistently thrilling, rather than just white-knuckle/scary for most (but not all) of its runtime.
Watch on Starz
4’Star Wars: The Last Jedi' (2017)
Oh boy. When it comes toStar Wars, most willagree that the original trilogy rocks, but regarding anything made after 1983, it’s a free-for-all. It’s a series that has so many fans and detractors at this point that consensus is impossible, and some won’t like hearing the suggestion thatStar Wars: The Last Jediis near-perfect; some might even be displeased at hearing something along the lines of “it’s pretty good.”
The Last Jeditakes risks and certainly packs an emotional punch, not to mention it looks spectacular and visually dazzling in a way that few otherStar Warsmovies have managed,and sounds as good as any of them. It explores the Force in an interesting way, builds a great dynamic between Kylo Ren and Rey, has its share of awe-inspiring moments, and does remarkable things with an older and more jaded Luke Skywalker (who resists his calling but overcomes then lives up to it in the final act, which detractors tend to overlook). That whole Canto Bight sequence, though?Detractors and fans alike will probably agree that it slows down the film or at least underwhelms compared to other sections, and it does contribute to the feeling ofThe Last Jedibeing uneven. But when it’s good, it soars – haters be damned.
Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi
3’Dune' (2021)
Director: Denis Villeneuve
This one’s a little bit of a tricky situation. In a post-Dune: Part Two(2024) world, 2021’sDunecan be fully appreciated as the first half ofan impressive two-parter; a duologythat nevertheless could still get sequels.Part Twowraps up the adaptation of the first book in theDuneseries, and watching both films back to back feels relatively satisfying.
Much of the exciting stuff happens inDune: Part Two, butDunestill has a lot to offer narratively and thematically, just not quite as much. A good deal of it’s set-up, andvery good set-up (and world-building) at that, but at a point,it does just sort of end. Being able to go straight intoDune: Part Twonowadays is nice, but for a while, 2021’s Dune was all there is, and its conclusion lacks a certain grace while also feeling abrupt.
Watch on Max
2’They Live' (1988)
Director: John Carpenter
John Carpenter’s made some movies that could be described as perfect, withHalloweenbeing a go-to/genre-defining slasher film, andThe Thinghaving atmosphere andspecial effects that put most modern productions to shame. Scrappier butjust as entertaining as those two would beThey Live, which is a thrilling blend of buddy comedy, action, satire, and sci-fi.
It’s a film that takes a little while to get going, but always feels like it’s going somewhere, especially by the time you get to thefamous “put the glasses on” action scenethat just goes on and on in the best way possible. On paper, the final act should be just as exciting, but it feels a bit rushed and slapped together compared to what came before. The wayThey Liveends is clever (and the final sequence is brilliant), but the roughness of the execution in that final 20 to 30-minute stretch leaves a little to be desired.
Rent on Apple TV
1’Inception' (2010)
Director: Christopher Nolan
Inceptionruns for about two and a half hours and moves for a mile a minute for most of that runtime. It’s an entertaining film that puts a sci-fi spin on the heist sub-genre, involving a team of people needing to plant an idea in an individual’s mind, which involves going into his dreams and exposing his subconscious to said idea.
It’s aChristopher Nolanmovie, soInceptionis naturally polished and exciting, though it lays the exposition on perhaps a little thick early on, and then drags ever so slightly as it lumbers toward a conclusion at the end of a final act that goes on just a touch too long.ButInceptionis still fantastic; perhaps even close to perfect, just not quite representative of Nolan at his very best. It’s close, though. Exceedingly close.
